Consumercarts is reader-supported. Learn more
Arctic P14 Max vs Phanteks SK123-140 D-RGB: Comparison
What is the difference between Arctic P14 Max and Phanteks SK123-140 D-RGB?
The gap that matters here is static pressure: Arctic P14 Max 4.18 mmH2O against Phanteks SK123-140 D-RGB 1.9 mmH2O, which puts Arctic P14 Max 55% ahead. Add airflow to that, 95 CFM on the Arctic P14 Max versus 74.0 CFM on the Phanteks SK123-140 D-RGB, and the pattern holds. Add max speed to that, 2800 RPM on the Arctic P14 Max versus 1500 RPM on the Phanteks SK123-140 D-RGB, and the pattern holds. There is a split on lighting as well, No RGB on the Arctic P14 Max versus D-RGB on the Phanteks SK123-140 D-RGB. They differ on positioning too, Performance on the Arctic P14 Max versus Mainstream on the Phanteks SK123-140 D-RGB.
Who each one is for
The Arctic P14 Max suits server and NAS builds prioritizing airflow over noise and extreme overclocking and test-bench cooling, though it is not built for quiet daily-driver builds and bedroom or office PCs. Buy the Phanteks SK123-140 D-RGB for 140mm case intake/exhaust and Phanteks case builds, though it is not the pick for radiator duty and silent builds. Our rating of the Arctic P14 Max (7/10): genuinely excellent cooling capacity for the size, but too loud at full speed for most home builds. Our rating of the Phanteks SK123-140 D-RGB (7/10): A well-rounded 140mm intake fan for Phanteks cases that want lighting without sacrificing airflow.
Where the two are identical
Where they agree, they agree completely, fan size, bearing type and pwm control included, so the decision does not turn on any of those.
Specs and benchmarks
Fan Size
- Arctic P14 Max
- 140 mm
- Phanteks SK123-140 D-RGB
- 140 mm
Brand
- Arctic P14 Max
- Arctic
- Phanteks SK123-140 D-RGB
- Phanteks
Model
- Arctic P14 Max
- P14 Max
- Phanteks SK123-140 D-RGB
- SK123-140 D-RGB
Bearing Type
- Arctic P14 Max
- Fluid Dynamic
- Phanteks SK123-140 D-RGB
- Fluid Dynamic
Lighting
- Arctic P14 Max
- No RGB
- Phanteks SK123-140 D-RGB
- D-RGB
Static Pressure
- Arctic P14 Max
- 4.18 mmH2OBest
- Phanteks SK123-140 D-RGB
- 1.9 mmH2O-55%
Max Speed
- Arctic P14 Max
- 2800 RPMBest
- Phanteks SK123-140 D-RGB
- 1500 RPM-46%
Airflow
- Arctic P14 Max
- 95 CFMBest
- Phanteks SK123-140 D-RGB
- 74.0 CFM-22%
PWM Control
- Arctic P14 Max
- Yes
- Phanteks SK123-140 D-RGB
- Yes
Positioning
- Arctic P14 Max
- Performance
- Phanteks SK123-140 D-RGB
- Mainstream
Which one should you pick?
Choose Arctic P14 Max if you want the higher static pressure (4.18 mmH2O vs 1.9 mmH2O), the higher max speed (2800 RPM vs 1500 RPM) and the higher airflow (95 CFM vs 74.0 CFM).
Choose Phanteks SK123-140 D-RGB if you already have it on hand or find it at a lower price.
Price comparison
| Retailer | Arctic P14 Max | Phanteks SK123-140 D-RGB |
|---|---|---|
| Amazon | View on Amazon | |
| Phanteks | View on Phanteks |
Disclaimer: The price and specification of the given product may differ from the actual product. Please confirm on the retailer's website before buying.
Verdict
Arctic P14 Max
7 / 10 Expert Rating
Genuinely excellent cooling capacity for the size, but too loud at full speed for most home builds.
Phanteks SK123-140 D-RGB
7 / 10 Expert Rating
A well-rounded 140mm intake fan for Phanteks cases that want lighting without sacrificing airflow.