Consumercarts is reader-supported. Learn more
ARCTIC Freezer 36 vs Fractal Design Lumen S24 v2: Comparison
ARCTIC Freezer 36 vs Fractal Design Lumen S24 v2: the warranty difference
On warranty the spread is 17%, ARCTIC Freezer 36 6 years against Fractal Design Lumen S24 v2 5 years, so ARCTIC Freezer 36 takes it. Add max speed to that, 1800 RPM on the ARCTIC Freezer 36 versus 2000 RPM on the Fractal Design Lumen S24 v2, and the pattern holds. They differ on bearing type too, Fluid Dynamic on the ARCTIC Freezer 36 versus Rifle on the Fractal Design Lumen S24 v2. There is a split on lighting as well, None on the ARCTIC Freezer 36 versus ARGB on the Fractal Design Lumen S24 v2.
Who each one is for
Buy the ARCTIC Freezer 36 for budget-conscious buyers upgrading directly from a stock cooler and mainstream non-overclocked builds needing roughly 200W of headroom, though it is the wrong buy for buyers wanting RGB lighting, since ARCTIC keeps this unlit. It is the wrong buy for overclocked or high-TDP builds, where direct-touch heatpipe designs generally lag brazed-base competitors. The Fractal Design Lumen S24 v2 is the one to take for budget 240mm-radiator builds wanting some RGB and Fractal Design case owners, though it is not built for High-TDP flagship CPUs needing 360mm cooling and buyers wanting maximum RGB brightness/effects. Our rating of the ARCTIC Freezer 36 (7.2/10): A perfectly serviceable entry-level upgrade over a stock cooler, without pretending to be more than that. Our rating of the Fractal Design Lumen S24 v2 (7.3/10): A budget-friendly 240mm AIO that adds tasteful RGB without a big price jump.
Frequently asked questions
Do the ARCTIC Freezer 36 and Fractal Design Lumen S24 v2 differ on cooler type?
Yes. Cooler Type reads Air Tower on the ARCTIC Freezer 36 versus AIO Liquid on the Fractal Design Lumen S24 v2.
Is the Fan Count the same on the ARCTIC Freezer 36 and Fractal Design Lumen S24 v2?
It is. Both are listed at 2, so it is not a reason to pick one over the other.
Specs and benchmarks
Brand
- ARCTIC Freezer 36
- ARCTIC
- Fractal Design Lumen S24 v2
- Fractal Design
Cooler Type
- ARCTIC Freezer 36
- Air Tower
- Fractal Design Lumen S24 v2
- AIO Liquid
Series
- ARCTIC Freezer 36
- ARCTIC Freezer 36
- Fractal Design Lumen S24 v2
- Fractal Design Lumen S24 v2
Model Number
- ARCTIC Freezer 36
- ACFRE00121A
- Fractal Design Lumen S24 v2
- FD-W-L1-S2412
Socket Compatibility
- ARCTIC Freezer 36
- AMD AM4/AM5, Intel LGA1851/1700
- Fractal Design Lumen S24 v2
- Intel LGA1851/1700/1200/1150/1151/1155/1156/1366/2011/2011-3/2066, AMD AM5/AM4/FM2+/FM2/FM1/AM3+/AM3/AM2+/AM2
Tower Layout
- ARCTIC Freezer 36
- Single-Tower
- Fractal Design Lumen S24 v2
- Not Applicable
Fan Count
- ARCTIC Freezer 36
- 2
- Fractal Design Lumen S24 v2
- 2
RGB Lighting
- ARCTIC Freezer 36
- No
- Fractal Design Lumen S24 v2
- Yes
Fan Size
- ARCTIC Freezer 36
- 120 mm
- Fractal Design Lumen S24 v2
- 120 mm
Max Speed
- ARCTIC Freezer 36
- 1800 RPM-10%
- Fractal Design Lumen S24 v2
- 2000 RPMBest
Bearing Type
- ARCTIC Freezer 36
- Fluid Dynamic
- Fractal Design Lumen S24 v2
- Rifle
PWM Control
- ARCTIC Freezer 36
- Yes
- Fractal Design Lumen S24 v2
- Yes
Lighting
- ARCTIC Freezer 36
- None
- Fractal Design Lumen S24 v2
- ARGB
Warranty
- ARCTIC Freezer 36
- 6 yearsBest
- Fractal Design Lumen S24 v2
- 5 years-17%
Which one should you pick?
Choose ARCTIC Freezer 36 if you want the higher fan count (2 vs 2) and the higher warranty (6 years vs 5 years).
Choose Fractal Design Lumen S24 v2 if you want the higher max speed (2000 RPM vs 1800 RPM).
Price comparison
| Retailer | ARCTIC Freezer 36 | Fractal Design Lumen S24 v2 |
|---|---|---|
| Amazon | View on Amazon | View on Amazon |
Disclaimer: The price and specification of the given product may differ from the actual product. Please confirm on the retailer's website before buying.
Verdict
ARCTIC Freezer 36
7.2 / 10 Expert Rating
A perfectly serviceable entry-level upgrade over a stock cooler, without pretending to be more than that.
Fractal Design Lumen S24 v2
7.3 / 10 Expert Rating
A budget-friendly 240mm AIO that adds tasteful RGB without a big price jump.