Consumercarts

Consumercarts is reader-supported. Learn more

IOGEAR CS1924A vs SmartAVI SDX-XT-4P-S: Comparison

IOGEAR CS1924A vs SmartAVI SDX-XT-4P-S: the max resolution difference

Start with max resolution, because it is the widest measured gap between them: IOGEAR CS1924A 7680x4320 against SmartAVI SDX-XT-4P-S 3840x2160, 75% in favour of IOGEAR CS1924A. IOGEAR CS1924A also leads on max resolution single display, 7680x4320 on the IOGEAR CS1924A versus 3840x2160 on the SmartAVI SDX-XT-4P-S. SmartAVI SDX-XT-4P-S also leads on usb hub ports, 3 on the IOGEAR CS1924A versus 4 on the SmartAVI SDX-XT-4P-S.

Who each one is for

The IOGEAR CS1924A suits government and enterprise buyers needing TAA-compliant high-resolution KVM hardware. It is equally the pick for professional desks with a single 8K-capable monitor shared across four computers. It is the wrong buy for dual-monitor workstations, the CS1942DPA covers that need across two computers instead of four. The SmartAVI SDX-XT-4P-S is the one to take for four-computer DisplayPort setups requiring CATx extension, though it is the wrong buy for setups needing more than 4 computers and HDMI-only environments. The same goes for facilities needing the console placed well away from the connected computers. It is not the one for standard desk distances where extension isn't needed (a SM-series switch is cheaper). Our rating of the IOGEAR CS1924A (8/10): A rare combination of 4-port switching and 8K resolution headroom, aimed at professional single-monitor, multi-machine desks. Our rating of the SmartAVI SDX-XT-4P-S (8/10): the right pick when a 4-computer DisplayPort KVM setup needs real distance between computers and console, not just switching.

IOGEAR CS1924A vs SmartAVI SDX-XT-4P-S price

Cost splits them too. IOGEAR CS1924A sits at $399, SmartAVI SDX-XT-4P-S at $1,282, 221% more.

Frequently asked questions

Do the IOGEAR CS1924A and SmartAVI SDX-XT-4P-S differ on displays per computer?

Yes. Displays Per Computer reads 1 displays on the IOGEAR CS1924A versus 4 displays on the SmartAVI SDX-XT-4P-S.

Is the Audio Support the same on the IOGEAR CS1924A and SmartAVI SDX-XT-4P-S?

It is. Both are listed at Yes, so it is not a reason to pick one over the other.

IOGEAR CS1924A (4-Port USB 3.0 8K DisplayPort KVMP Switch)
IOGEAR
IOGEAR CS1924A

$399.00

Consumercarts listing

@ Consumercarts listing ›
SmartAVI SDX-XT-4P-S (4-Port Extended KVM Switch)
SmartAVI
SmartAVI SDX-XT-4P-S

$1,282.26

Consumercarts listing

@ Consumercarts listing ›

Specs and benchmarks

  • Capability Score

    IOGEAR CS1924A
    6.7/10Best
    SmartAVI SDX-XT-4P-S
    6.7/10Best

    How much this switch can do, rated from its video support, monitor handling, USB speed and switching options. 10 is the most capable.

  • Brand

    IOGEAR CS1924A
    IOGEAR
    SmartAVI SDX-XT-4P-S
    SmartAVI

  • Computers Supported

    IOGEAR CS1924A
    4 computers
    SmartAVI SDX-XT-4P-S
    4 computers

  • Model Number

    IOGEAR CS1924A
    CS1924A
    SmartAVI SDX-XT-4P-S
    SDX-XT-4P-S

  • Displays Per Computer

    IOGEAR CS1924A
    1 displays
    SmartAVI SDX-XT-4P-S
    4 displays

  • Switching Method

    IOGEAR CS1924A
    Push-button / hotkey
    SmartAVI SDX-XT-4P-S
    Button, hotkey, software, extended reach

  • Video Standard

    IOGEAR CS1924A
    DisplayPort
    SmartAVI SDX-XT-4P-S
    DisplayPort

  • Max Resolution

    IOGEAR CS1924A
    8KBest
    SmartAVI SDX-XT-4P-S
    4K@60Hz-75%

  • USB Hub Ports

    IOGEAR CS1924A
    3-25%
    SmartAVI SDX-XT-4P-S
    4Best

  • KVM Segment

    IOGEAR CS1924A
    Desk
    SmartAVI SDX-XT-4P-S
    Desk

  • Audio Support

    IOGEAR CS1924A
    Yes
    SmartAVI SDX-XT-4P-S
    Yes

  • Max Resolution Single Display

    IOGEAR CS1924A
    7680x4320Best
    SmartAVI SDX-XT-4P-S
    3840x2160-75%

  • USB Switching Speed

    IOGEAR CS1924A
    USB 3.0 5GbpsBest
    SmartAVI SDX-XT-4P-S
    USB 2.0

  • Price

    IOGEAR CS1924A
    399.00 USD
    SmartAVI SDX-XT-4P-S
    1282.26 USD

    Which one should you pick?

    Choose IOGEAR CS1924A if you want the higher max resolution (8K vs 4K@60Hz) and the higher max resolution single display (7680x4320 vs 3840x2160).

    Choose SmartAVI SDX-XT-4P-S if you want the higher USB hub ports (4 vs 3).

    Price comparison

    RetailerIOGEAR CS1924ASmartAVI SDX-XT-4P-S
    Consumercarts listing

    $399.00

    View on Consumercarts listing

    $1,282.26

    View on Consumercarts listing

    Disclaimer: The price and specification of the given product may differ from the actual product. Please confirm on the retailer's website before buying.

    Verdict

    IOGEAR CS1924A

    8 / 10 Expert Rating

    A rare combination of 4-port switching and 8K resolution headroom, aimed at professional single-monitor, multi-machine desks.

    SmartAVI SDX-XT-4P-S

    8 / 10 Expert Rating

    The right pick when a 4-computer DisplayPort KVM setup needs real distance between computers and console, not just switching.

    Compare IOGEAR CS1924A with