Consumercarts is reader-supported. Learn more
ADATA AX5U5200C3816G-B 16GB DDR5-5200 CL38 Bare/Tray Module vs Crucial CT8G56C46U5.M4G1 8GB: Comparison
What is the difference between ADATA AX5U5200C3816G-B 16GB DDR5-5200 and Crucial CT8G56C46U5.M4G1 8GB?
Capacity is where these two genuinely part company, ADATA AX5U5200C3816G-B 16GB DDR5-5200 16 GB against Crucial CT8G56C46U5.M4G1 8GB 8 GB, a 50% lead for ADATA AX5U5200C3816G-B 16GB DDR5-5200. Measured rather than claimed: in Speed Score the Crucial CT8G56C46U5.M4G1 8GB returns 6 against 5.5, a 8% lead. Add capacity per module to that, 16 GB on the ADATA AX5U5200C3816G-B 16GB DDR5-5200 versus 8 GB on the Crucial CT8G56C46U5.M4G1 8GB, and the pattern holds. ADATA AX5U5200C3816G-B 16GB DDR5-5200 also leads on cas latency, 38 on the ADATA AX5U5200C3816G-B 16GB DDR5-5200 versus 46 on the Crucial CT8G56C46U5.M4G1 8GB. The speed figures are near enough to ignore, 5200 MT/s on the ADATA AX5U5200C3816G-B 16GB DDR5-5200 versus 5600 MT/s on the Crucial CT8G56C46U5.M4G1 8GB. ADATA AX5U5200C3816G-B 16GB DDR5-5200 also leads on true latency, 14.6 ns on the ADATA AX5U5200C3816G-B 16GB DDR5-5200 versus 16.4 ns on the Crucial CT8G56C46U5.M4G1 8GB. The peak bandwidth figures are near enough to ignore, 41.6 GB/s on the ADATA AX5U5200C3816G-B 16GB DDR5-5200 versus 44.8 GB/s on the Crucial CT8G56C46U5.M4G1 8GB.
Who each one is for
The ADATA AX5U5200C3816G-B 16GB DDR5-5200 suits system builders and OEM configurations and budget upgrades where brand styling doesn't matter, though it is not the pick for gaming or performance-focused builds. The Crucial CT8G56C46U5.M4G1 8GB is the one to take for adding a second 8GB stick to an existing single-module PC and budget office or light-use desktop builds, though it is not built for gaming or content-creation builds (too little capacity) and buyers wanting XMP-tuned speeds.
What ADATA AX5U5200C3816G-B 16GB DDR5-5200 and Crucial CT8G56C46U5.M4G1 8GB have in common
Everything else lines up. Ddr generation, module count, ram segment and form factor read the same on both, so those are not worth weighing.
Specs and benchmarks
Speed Score
- ADATA AX5U5200C3816G-B 16GB DDR5-5200 CL38 Bare/Tray Module
- 5.5/10-8%
- Crucial CT8G56C46U5.M4G1 8GB
- 6.0/10Best
How fast this kit is for its memory type, rated from its speed and latency. 10 is the fastest.
DDR Generation
- ADATA AX5U5200C3816G-B 16GB DDR5-5200 CL38 Bare/Tray Module
- DDR5
- Crucial CT8G56C46U5.M4G1 8GB
- DDR5
Brand
- ADATA AX5U5200C3816G-B 16GB DDR5-5200 CL38 Bare/Tray Module
- ADATA
- Crucial CT8G56C46U5.M4G1 8GB
- Crucial
Capacity
- ADATA AX5U5200C3816G-B 16GB DDR5-5200 CL38 Bare/Tray Module
- 16 GBBest
- Crucial CT8G56C46U5.M4G1 8GB
- 8 GB-50%
Part Number
- ADATA AX5U5200C3816G-B 16GB DDR5-5200 CL38 Bare/Tray Module
- AX5U5200C3816G-B
- Crucial CT8G56C46U5.M4G1 8GB
- CT8G56C46U5.M4G1
Speed
- ADATA AX5U5200C3816G-B 16GB DDR5-5200 CL38 Bare/Tray Module
- 5200 MT/s-7%
- Crucial CT8G56C46U5.M4G1 8GB
- 5600 MT/sBest
CAS Latency
- ADATA AX5U5200C3816G-B 16GB DDR5-5200 CL38 Bare/Tray Module
- 38Best
- Crucial CT8G56C46U5.M4G1 8GB
- 46-21%
Module Count
- ADATA AX5U5200C3816G-B 16GB DDR5-5200 CL38 Bare/Tray Module
- 1
- Crucial CT8G56C46U5.M4G1 8GB
- 1
RAM Segment
- ADATA AX5U5200C3816G-B 16GB DDR5-5200 CL38 Bare/Tray Module
- Desktop DDR5
- Crucial CT8G56C46U5.M4G1 8GB
- Desktop DDR5
Form Factor
- ADATA AX5U5200C3816G-B 16GB DDR5-5200 CL38 Bare/Tray Module
- Desktop DIMM
- Crucial CT8G56C46U5.M4G1 8GB
- Desktop DIMM
Capacity Per Module
- ADATA AX5U5200C3816G-B 16GB DDR5-5200 CL38 Bare/Tray Module
- 16 GBBest
- Crucial CT8G56C46U5.M4G1 8GB
- 8 GB-50%
True Latency
- ADATA AX5U5200C3816G-B 16GB DDR5-5200 CL38 Bare/Tray Module
- 14.6 nsBest
- Crucial CT8G56C46U5.M4G1 8GB
- 16.4 ns-12%
Peak Bandwidth
- ADATA AX5U5200C3816G-B 16GB DDR5-5200 CL38 Bare/Tray Module
- 41.6 GB/s-7%
- Crucial CT8G56C46U5.M4G1 8GB
- 44.8 GB/sBest
Which one should you pick?
Choose ADATA AX5U5200C3816G-B 16GB DDR5-5200 CL38 Bare/Tray Module if you want the higher capacity (16 GB vs 8 GB), the lower CAS latency (38 vs 46) and the higher capacity per module (16 GB vs 8 GB).
Choose Crucial CT8G56C46U5.M4G1 8GB if you want the higher speed score (6.0 vs 5.5), the higher speed (5600 MT/s vs 5200 MT/s) and the higher peak bandwidth (44.8 GB/s vs 41.6 GB/s).
Price comparison
| Retailer | ADATA AX5U5200C3816G-B 16GB DDR5-5200 CL38 Bare/Tray Module | Crucial CT8G56C46U5.M4G1 8GB |
|---|---|---|
| Amazon | View on Amazon |
Disclaimer: The price and specification of the given product may differ from the actual product. Please confirm on the retailer's website before buying.
More comparisons in RAM
Compare ADATA AX5U5200C3816G-B 16GB DDR5-5200 CL38 Bare/Tray Module with
- ADATA AX5U5200C3816G-B 16GB DDR5-5200 CL38 Bare/Tray Module vs ADATA AX5U5200C388G-B 8GB DDR5-5200 CL38 Bare/Tray Module
- ADATA AX5U5200C3816G-B 16GB DDR5-5200 CL38 Bare/Tray Module vs ADATA XPG Caster RGB AX5U5200C388G-DCCARGY (16GB (2x8GB)/DDR5 5200MHz/CL38/RGB Gray)
- ADATA AX5U5200C3816G-B 16GB DDR5-5200 CL38 Bare/Tray Module vs ADATA XPG Lancer RGB AX5U5200C3816G-DCLARBK (32GB (2x16GB)/DDR5 5200MHz/CL38/RGB Black)
- ADATA AX5U5200C3816G-B 16GB DDR5-5200 CL38 Bare/Tray Module vs Corsair CMK48GX5M2B5200C38 (48GB 2x24GB Kit/DDR5 5200MT/s/CL38)