Consumercarts is reader-supported. Learn more
Acer FA200 vs Crucial P5: Comparison
Acer FA200 vs Crucial P5 sequential read compared
Start with sequential read, because it is the widest measured gap between them: Acer FA200 7200 MB/s against Crucial P5 3400 MB/s, 53% in favour of Acer FA200. Measured rather than claimed: in Speed Score the Crucial P5 returns 7.1 against 6.6, a 7% lead. Sequential write runs the same way, 6200 MB/s on the Acer FA200 versus 3000 MB/s on the Crucial P5, another win for Acer FA200. There is a split on dram cache as well, DRAM-less on the Acer FA200 versus DRAM on the Crucial P5.
Which should you buy, Acer FA200 or Crucial P5?
Take the Acer FA200 for gamers and general users wanting 2000 GB of PCIe 4.0 storage at high read speeds. The same goes for buyers who value a 5 year warranty and a 1000 TBW rating. It is the wrong buy for workloads with constant heavy writing, since the NAND is QLC and the drive has no DRAM. Take the Crucial P5 for PCIe 3.0-only systems where Gen 4 bandwidth would go unused anyway. It also earns its place with buyers who specifically want Crucial's in-house NAND and DRAM cache combination on a Gen 3 drive. It is not the one for anyone with a PCIe 4.0-capable motherboard. Crucial's own P5 Plus, covered elsewhere on this site, nearly doubles the bandwidth for a modest price step up. Our rating of the Crucial P5 (7.3/10): A solid, dependable Gen 3 drive from a trusted brand, now mostly superseded by Crucial's own P5 Plus.
Frequently asked questions
Do the Acer FA200 and Crucial P5 differ on bus interface?
Yes. Bus Interface reads PCIe 4.0 x4 on the Acer FA200 versus PCIe 3.0 x4, NVMe on the Crucial P5.
Is the Form Factor the same on the Acer FA200 and Crucial P5?
It is. Both are listed at M.2 2280, so it is not a reason to pick one over the other.
Specs and benchmarks
Speed Score
- Acer FA200
- 6.6/10-7%
- Crucial P5
- 7.1/10Best
How fast this drive is, rated from its read and write speeds, cache and NAND type. 10 is the fastest.
Brand
- Acer FA200
- Acer
- Crucial P5
- Crucial (Micron)
Model Number
- Acer FA200
- Acer FA200
- Crucial P5
- P5
Series
- Acer FA200
- FA200
- Crucial P5
- P5
Drive Type
- Acer FA200
- Internal
- Crucial P5
- Internal
Bus Interface
- Acer FA200
- PCIe 4.0 x4
- Crucial P5
- PCIe 3.0 x4, NVMe
Form Factor
- Acer FA200
- M.2 2280
- Crucial P5
- M.2 2280
Sequential Read
- Acer FA200
- 7200 MB/s
- Crucial P5
- 3400 MB/s-53%
Sequential Write
- Acer FA200
- 6200 MB/s
- Crucial P5
- 3000 MB/s-52%
DRAM Cache
- Acer FA200
- DRAM-less (HMB)
- Crucial P5
- DRAM
NAND Type
- Acer FA200
- QLC
- Crucial P5
- TLC
Warranty
- Acer FA200
- 5 Years
- Crucial P5
- 5 Years
Which one should you pick?
Choose Acer FA200 if you want the higher sequential read (7200 MB/s vs 3400 MB/s) and the higher sequential write (6200 MB/s vs 3000 MB/s).
Choose Crucial P5 if you want the higher speed score (7.1 vs 6.6).
Price comparison
| Retailer | Acer FA200 | Crucial P5 |
|---|---|---|
| Amazon | View on Amazon |
Disclaimer: The price and specification of the given product may differ from the actual product. Please confirm on the retailer's website before buying.
Verdict
Crucial P5
7.3 / 10 Expert Rating
A solid, dependable Gen 3 drive from a trusted brand, now mostly superseded by Crucial's own P5 Plus.