Consumercarts is reader-supported. Learn more
Adder Technology Adder ALIF1002P vs SmartAVI SM-EDPN-4D-S: Comparison
What is the difference between Adder Technology Adder ALIF1002P and SmartAVI SM-EDPN-4D-S?
The gap that matters here is max resolution single display: Adder Technology Adder ALIF1002P 1920x1200 against SmartAVI SM-EDPN-4D-S 3840x2160, which puts SmartAVI SM-EDPN-4D-S 72% ahead. Add usb hub ports to that, 2 on the Adder Technology Adder ALIF1002P versus 3 on the SmartAVI SM-EDPN-4D-S, and the pattern holds. They differ on kvm segment too, Extender on the Adder Technology Adder ALIF1002P versus Desk on the SmartAVI SM-EDPN-4D-S.
Who each one is for
The Adder Technology Adder ALIF1002P suits enterprise IP KVM matrix deployments centered on DVI video and facilities already using Adder's ADDERLink Infinity Manager, though it is the wrong buy for multi-monitor workstations needing dual-head DVI, where the ALIF2112T fits better and HDMI or DisplayPort-based workstations. It is equally the pick for buyers wanting a complete matched transmitter/receiver pair rather than individual nodes. Avoid it for small single-room extension budgets, where the Emerald EMD2000PE-T costs roughly half as much. Buy the SmartAVI SM-EDPN-4D-S for dual-monitor DisplayPort desks needing four sources and engineering and CAD workstations, though it is not built for quad-monitor requirements (see SM-EDPN-4Q-S) and single-monitor setups. Our rating of the Adder Technology Adder ALIF1002P (7/10): A capable enterprise DVI network extender pair, priced for serious IP KVM matrix deployments rather than single-room extension. Our rating of the SmartAVI SM-EDPN-4D-S (7.9/10): A solid discounted dual-head DisplayPort option; the plain SM-DPN-4D-S may suffice for buyers not needing EDPN's extras.
Which is cheaper, Adder Technology Adder ALIF1002P or SmartAVI SM-EDPN-4D-S?
At the last price check the SmartAVI SM-EDPN-4D-S was $856 and the Adder Technology Adder ALIF1002P $3,051, a 256% premium.
Frequently asked questions
Do the Adder Technology Adder ALIF1002P and SmartAVI SM-EDPN-4D-S differ on computers supported?
Yes. Computers Supported reads 1 computers on the Adder Technology Adder ALIF1002P versus 4 computers on the SmartAVI SM-EDPN-4D-S.
Is the Max Refresh At Max Resolution the same on the Adder Technology Adder ALIF1002P and SmartAVI SM-EDPN-4D-S?
It is. Both are listed at 1920x1200, so it is not a reason to pick one over the other.
Specs and benchmarks
Capability Score
- Adder Technology Adder ALIF1002P
- 6.8/10
- SmartAVI SM-EDPN-4D-S
- 6.1/10
These are different kinds of KVM, scored on separate scales, so the two scores can't be compared directly.
Brand
- Adder Technology Adder ALIF1002P
- Adder
- SmartAVI SM-EDPN-4D-S
- SmartAVI
Computers Supported
- Adder Technology Adder ALIF1002P
- 1 computers
- SmartAVI SM-EDPN-4D-S
- 4 computers
Model Number
- Adder Technology Adder ALIF1002P
- ALIF1002P
- SmartAVI SM-EDPN-4D-S
- SM-EDPN-4D-S
Displays Per Computer
- Adder Technology Adder ALIF1002P
- 1 displays
- SmartAVI SM-EDPN-4D-S
- 2 displays
Video Standard
- Adder Technology Adder ALIF1002P
- DVI
- SmartAVI SM-EDPN-4D-S
- DisplayPort (dual-head)
Max Resolution
- Adder Technology Adder ALIF1002P
- 1920x1200 @ 60Hz-72%
- SmartAVI SM-EDPN-4D-S
- 4K@60Hz per headBest
USB Hub Ports
- Adder Technology Adder ALIF1002P
- 2-33%
- SmartAVI SM-EDPN-4D-S
- 3Best
KVM Segment
- Adder Technology Adder ALIF1002P
- Extender
- SmartAVI SM-EDPN-4D-S
- Desk
Audio Support
- Adder Technology Adder ALIF1002P
- Yes
- SmartAVI SM-EDPN-4D-S
- Yes
Max Resolution Single Display
- Adder Technology Adder ALIF1002P
- 1920x1200-72%
- SmartAVI SM-EDPN-4D-S
- 3840x2160Best
Max Refresh At Max Resolution
- Adder Technology Adder ALIF1002P
- 60 Hz-72%
- SmartAVI SM-EDPN-4D-S
- 60 HzBest
USB Switching Speed
- Adder Technology Adder ALIF1002P
- USB 2.0
- SmartAVI SM-EDPN-4D-S
- USB 2.0
Price
- Adder Technology Adder ALIF1002P
- 3051.40 USD
- SmartAVI SM-EDPN-4D-S
- 856.36 USD
Which one should you pick?
Choose Adder Technology Adder ALIF1002P if you already have it on hand or find it at a lower price.
Choose SmartAVI SM-EDPN-4D-S if you want the higher max resolution (4K@60Hz per head vs 1920x1200 @ 60Hz), the higher USB hub ports (3 vs 2) and the higher max resolution single display (3840x2160 vs 1920x1200).
Price comparison
| Retailer | Adder Technology Adder ALIF1002P | SmartAVI SM-EDPN-4D-S |
|---|---|---|
| Consumercarts listing | $3,051.40 View on Consumercarts listing | $856.36 View on Consumercarts listing |
Disclaimer: The price and specification of the given product may differ from the actual product. Please confirm on the retailer's website before buying.
Verdict
Adder Technology Adder ALIF1002P
7 / 10 Expert Rating
A capable enterprise DVI network extender pair, priced for serious IP KVM matrix deployments rather than single-room extension.
SmartAVI SM-EDPN-4D-S
7.9 / 10 Expert Rating
A solid discounted dual-head DisplayPort option; the plain SM-DPN-4D-S may suffice for buyers not needing EDPN's extras.
More comparisons in KVM Switches
Compare Adder Technology Adder ALIF1002P with
- Adder Technology Adder ALIF1002P vs ADDERLink ALIF2112T (Dual Link/Dual Head DVI Extender)
- Adder Technology Adder ALIF1002P vs ATEN KX9970FR (5K DisplayPort KVM-over-IP Receiver, Fiber)
- Adder Technology Adder ALIF1002P vs ATEN KX9970FT (5K DisplayPort KVM-over-IP Transmitter, Fiber)
- Adder Technology Adder ALIF1002P vs Adder ALIF1104T (HDMI KVM-over-IP Transmitter over 1GbE)