Consumercarts is reader-supported. Learn more
HP N59788-005 Replacement Battery vs HP P23104-001 Replacement Battery: Comparison
What is the difference between N59788-005 Replacement Battery and P23104-001 Replacement Battery?
On capacity wh the spread is 18%, N59788-005 Replacement Battery 68 Wh against P23104-001 Replacement Battery 83 Wh, so P23104-001 Replacement Battery takes it. The battery model code figures are near enough to ignore, N59788-005 on the N59788-005 Replacement Battery versus P23104-001 on the P23104-001 Replacement Battery. They differ on oem spare part number too, P05235-001 on the N59788-005 Replacement Battery versus P23103-001 on the P23104-001 Replacement Battery. There is a split on compatible models as well, HP EliteBook 1040 G11 on the N59788-005 Replacement Battery versus HP Omen 16 2025 on the P23104-001 Replacement Battery.
Who each one is for
Buy the N59788-005 Replacement Battery for EliteBook 1040 G11 owners with the 6-cell configuration, though it is the wrong buy for EliteBook 1040 G11 units with the smaller 3-cell P05235-001 pack. The P23104-001 Replacement Battery is the one to take for omen 16 2025 RTX 4070 configuration owners, though it is not built for lower-tier Omen 16 2025 configurations using the 70Wh pack.
Where the two are identical
The common ground is wider than the gap: cell count, capacity basis, expected firmware state and shipping classification are identical here.
Specs and benchmarks
Brand
- HP N59788-005 Replacement Battery
- HP
- HP P23104-001 Replacement Battery
- HP
Battery Model Code
- HP N59788-005 Replacement Battery
- N59788-005Best
- HP P23104-001 Replacement Battery
- P23104-001
OEM Spare Part Number
- HP N59788-005 Replacement Battery
- P05235-001 (3-cell 56Wh alternate)
- HP P23104-001 Replacement Battery
- P23103-001 (4-cell 70Wh alternate)
Cell Count
- HP N59788-005 Replacement Battery
- 6
- HP P23104-001 Replacement Battery
- 6
Capacity Wh
- HP N59788-005 Replacement Battery
- 68 Wh-18%
- HP P23104-001 Replacement Battery
- 83 WhBest
Capacity Basis
- HP N59788-005 Replacement Battery
- OEM Label
- HP P23104-001 Replacement Battery
- OEM Label
Expected Firmware State
- HP N59788-005 Replacement Battery
- full_function
- HP P23104-001 Replacement Battery
- full_function
Shipping Classification
- HP N59788-005 Replacement Battery
- UN3481
- HP P23104-001 Replacement Battery
- UN3481
Compatible Models
- HP N59788-005 Replacement Battery
- HP EliteBook 1040 G11 (Core Ultra 7 165U, 16GB, 512GB)
- HP P23104-001 Replacement Battery
- HP Omen 16 2025 (Ryzen 9 8945HX, RTX 4070, 32GB)
Which one should you pick?
Choose HP N59788-005 Replacement Battery if you already have it on hand or find it at a lower price.
Choose HP P23104-001 Replacement Battery if you want the higher capacity wh (83 Wh vs 68 Wh).