Consumercarts is reader-supported. Learn more
Dell WD19S vs HP Thunderbolt Dock G4: Comparison
Dell WD19S vs HP Thunderbolt Dock G4: the host power delivery difference
Start with host power delivery, because it is the widest measured gap between them: Dell WD19S 90 W against HP Thunderbolt Dock G4 100 W, 10% in favour of HP Thunderbolt Dock G4. There is a split on downstream thunderbolt port count as well, 0 on the Dell WD19S versus 1 on the HP Thunderbolt Dock G4.
Who each one is for
The Dell WD19S is the one to take for standard office desks with a single external monitor and Dell laptop fleets where budget matters more than Thunderbolt speed, though it is the wrong buy for dual-monitor or multi-display desk setups and users wanting Thunderbolt-level bandwidth. Take the HP Thunderbolt Dock G4 for home offices standardizing on the same dock as a company-issued HP fleet laptop. It also earns its place with buyers who found one through a business surplus/refurb channel at a discount. It is the wrong buy for anyone wanting the widest possible port selection, dedicated consumer docks often pack in more. Our rating of the Dell WD19S (6/10): A reliable, no-frills budget dock for single-monitor Dell office desks. Our rating of the HP Thunderbolt Dock G4 (7/10): A stable, fleet-grade Thunderbolt 4 dock that's a bargain if you find one through business channels.
What Dell WD19S and HP Thunderbolt Dock G4 have in common
Where they agree, they agree completely, ethernet, bus powered, max displays windows, max dual display resolution and max dual display refresh included, so the decision does not turn on any of those. They match on 6 further specifications as well.
Frequently asked questions
Do the Dell WD19S and HP Thunderbolt Dock G4 differ on ethernet speed?
Yes. Ethernet Speed reads 1GbE on the Dell WD19S versus 2.5GbE on the HP Thunderbolt Dock G4.
Is the HDMI Port Count the same on the Dell WD19S and HP Thunderbolt Dock G4?
It is. Both are listed at 1, so it is not a reason to pick one over the other.
Specs and benchmarks
Brand
- Dell WD19S
- Dell
- HP Thunderbolt Dock G4
- HP
Connection Type
- Dell WD19S
- USB-C (USB 3.2 Gen 2, non-Thunderbolt)
- HP Thunderbolt Dock G4
- Thunderbolt 4
Host Interface
- Dell WD19S
- USB-C 3.2 Gen 2
- HP Thunderbolt Dock G4
- Thunderbolt 4
Model Number
- Dell WD19S
- WD19S
- HP Thunderbolt Dock G4
- Thunderbolt Dock G4
Port Configuration
- Dell WD19S
- 1x USB-C upstream, 2x DisplayPort++ 1.4, 1x HDMI 2.0 (shared with rear USB-C DP), 3x USB-A 5Gbps, 2x USB-C 10Gbps (rear with DP 1.4), 1x GbE
- HP Thunderbolt Dock G4
- 1x TB4 downstream, 2x DisplayPort 1.4, 1x HDMI 2.0, 1x rear USB-C DisplayPort, 1x front USB-C 10Gbps (15W), 2x USB-A 10Gbps, 2x USB-A 5Gbps, 2.5GbE RJ45
Thunderbolt Version
- Dell WD19S
- None
- HP Thunderbolt Dock G4
- 4
Host Cable Length
- Dell WD19S
- 1 m
- HP Thunderbolt Dock G4
- 0.8 m
Host Power Delivery
- Dell WD19S
- 90 W-10%
- HP Thunderbolt Dock G4
- 100 W
Ethernet
- Dell WD19S
- Yes
- HP Thunderbolt Dock G4
- Yes
External PSU Wattage
- Dell WD19S
- 130 WBest
- HP Thunderbolt Dock G4
- 120 W
Bus Powered
- Dell WD19S
- No
- HP Thunderbolt Dock G4
- No
Max Displays Windows
- Dell WD19S
- 4
- HP Thunderbolt Dock G4
- 4
Max Dual Display Resolution
- Dell WD19S
- 4K
- HP Thunderbolt Dock G4
- 4K
Max Dual Display Refresh
- Dell WD19S
- 60 Hz
- HP Thunderbolt Dock G4
- 60 Hz
HDMI Port Count
- Dell WD19S
- 1
- HP Thunderbolt Dock G4
- 1
HDMI Version
- Dell WD19S
- 2.0
- HP Thunderbolt Dock G4
- 2.0
DisplayPort Port Count
- Dell WD19S
- 2
- HP Thunderbolt Dock G4
- 2
DisplayPort Version
- Dell WD19S
- 1.4
- HP Thunderbolt Dock G4
- 1.4
USB-C Video Output Count
- Dell WD19S
- 1
- HP Thunderbolt Dock G4
- 1
Downstream Thunderbolt Port Count
- Dell WD19S
- 0
- HP Thunderbolt Dock G4
- 1
USB-A Port Count
- Dell WD19S
- 3
- HP Thunderbolt Dock G4
- 4
USB-C Data Port Count
- Dell WD19S
- 2
- HP Thunderbolt Dock G4
- 1
Max USB Data Rate
- Dell WD19S
- 10Gbps
- HP Thunderbolt Dock G4
- 10Gbps
Ethernet Speed
- Dell WD19S
- 1GbE
- HP Thunderbolt Dock G4
- 2.5GbEBest
Weight
- Dell WD19S
- 590 gBest
- HP Thunderbolt Dock G4
- 762 g
Which one should you pick?
Choose Dell WD19S if you already have it on hand or find it at a lower price.
Choose HP Thunderbolt Dock G4 if you want the higher host power delivery (100 W vs 90 W).
Price comparison
| Retailer | Dell WD19S | HP Thunderbolt Dock G4 |
|---|---|---|
| Newegg | $150.00 View on Newegg | View on Newegg |
Disclaimer: The price and specification of the given product may differ from the actual product. Please confirm on the retailer's website before buying.
Verdict
Dell WD19S
6 / 10 Expert Rating
A reliable, no-frills budget dock for single-monitor Dell office desks.
HP Thunderbolt Dock G4
7 / 10 Expert Rating
A stable, fleet-grade Thunderbolt 4 dock that's a bargain if you find one through business channels.